I am not a professional photographer by any means, nor would I consider myself an amateur. I am just a person who likes to take varied photos. Whether it is the zoo, bouldering, cars, my desk or people I am always learning and discovering new things about taking photos (the resulting photo and the process itself). I picked up post processing only just recently and I am happy with the results I have come up with, but I definitely recognize I need to improve and that I shouldn’t use it as a crutch. With that said I don’t crop the photos I take. I am not sure if this is related to a small case of OCD and liking uniformity with my digital possesions, but I just don’t do it. I don’t look down on people who don’t, as I don’t look down on people who don’t post process.
This evening I was chatting with a friend who I take pictures with every so often. This person mentioned a ‘photography snob’ who never cropped their photos and always wanted to frame the photo just right or they would not take the photo. I can understand this and it seems reasonable. Then this snob recommended using lightroom. Wait a minute, this seems odd to me. Maybe I am the only one who thinks so, but this seems a wee bit hypocritical. Philoshipically, it seems hard to rationlize being adverse to cropping, but not post processing.
My only response was to tell them to wait for the next time this snob was trying to perfectly frame their photo to ask about lighting and if it wasn’t perfect they should wait until the light was perfect before taking the photo.
In the end every photographer has their own techniques and ‘moral compass’, but to miss out on a photo opportunity because you did’t want to drop seems like it would you to not capture a lot of candid moments, but hey, maybe this snob only wants to shoot portrait photography. Even when I asked my brother about this contradiction he asked me in reply “isn’t half the fun of photography seeing what you can do with it on the computer?”. The moral of the story is, photography means something different to everyone and find what makes you happy and do it.
If you really want to argue either way here are some articles I thought were good starters.